Friday, November 20, 2009

Stocks (Market) that puzzle

The relation between stock price and its earnings is well known and most of the investors believe that stock price is the function of earnings. But there also exists some “other” phenomenon which I do not have clear idea about and I am sure many people are in the same boat. The stocks that I am going to mention about are trading relatively with huge volumes these days. I do know that stocks of some of the companies with good growth opportunities are fully priced in well before the “so called” earnings are realized. But what I do not understand is the fact that some of these companies have not even announced the opportunities that exist but are hot favorites in the market. Let’s see one by one.

BF Utilities (Price: Rs.1356)

This is the company promoted by Kalyani Group to meet their own power requirement. The total capacity of the power plants is 19 MW according to their website. Sales per year stand at mere 20 crores and the EPS is around 1.5 rupees. Book value is Rs.60. Just a month back, this stock was trading at Rs.752 (Nov 3, 2009) and I have not read any path breaking corporate announcements since then. But the stock is trading now at Rs. 1356 (PE Ratio of 1100), whopping 80% increase within 40 days. In fact over 2.5 lakh shares were traded on Friday (Nov 20, 2009). Market cap stands at 5100 crores.
The only reason that I can think of for this huge unbelievable valuation is that they have set up wind farms to generate power and people might be thinking that they would venture into wind power industry. Even with that scenario, the stock price is not justified. As of now it is a captive power plant for kalyani group which is the truth. If anyone understands better or have more information, please share in the comments section.

Shree Global Tradefin Ltd

Price: Rs.428
Market Cap: 8800 Crores
Revenue/Year: 307 Crores

EPS and thus PE ratio is in the negatives. Book Value can’t be mentioned here. What kind of growth opportunities investors foresee in a company like this is not well understood. In the earlier days, companies like Airtel and Praj Industries had to prove their worth to command higher valuations. But the days have changed where companies attract huge investor base just based on the “assumed” opportunities which is not a healthy sign for a real investor. It might well turn out to be true that this company might become a giant and reward the share holders handsomely but my point is, would Warren Buffet invest in a company like this? Would Benjamin Graham spend a minute to look at the financials of this stock? I strongly suspect that happening. Even if the traders and investors found something special in these companies, how did they come up with the earnings projections that command these valuations?

Kwality Dairy

Price: Rs. 1197
EPS: Rs.5.26
PE: 227
Book Value: Rs. 11
Sales/Year: Rs.583 Crores

Even though I knew about this stock for a long time, I never bothered to look it up. But one of my blogging friend’s Shabu mentioned this stock in his blog and I wondered what on earth increased this stock price from mere Rs.20 in Nov, 2008 to Rs.1200 in Nov, 2009. The price has increased 60 times in a year (You are right, 6000% return in a year) but I do not know if the investors realized the increase in sales or earnings have not grown anywhere near. I wish I have the ability to spot this speculative trend so that I do not need to work anymore!!! To find few more stocks like this, you can go to the following link.

Likewise there are several other companies commanding very high valuations based on the “Assumed” or “Projected” growth opportunities and I have mentioned some of them below as these stocks have been in the limelight more in the past week.

Jai Corp
Dynamatic Technologies Ltd
Edserv Soft systems

I have mentioned my points based on what I have read, but there could have been some reasons for which the companies are commanding high valuation that I might have missed. If anyone knows about that, please comment on it.

Kumaran Seenivasan


Madan Kumar November 21, 2009 at 1:36 PM  

Dear Kumaran,

If market behaves rationally there will be no space for investing at all. Everything will be just speculation. The above stock prices and those which Shabu listed few weeks back just show how mad market can become for no reason.

Madan Kumar Rajan N

Faisal Humayun November 25, 2009 at 6:49 AM  

For sure there is plenty of room for speculation in the Indian markets...Market operators play with small stocks which have very low free float and drive prices up...

I saw a report on ET maybe a few weeks back which talked about some online recommendations given on unknown stocks...The objective is to offload the stocks after the operators have driven the prices higher and made profits...

So at times stocks defy times the entire markets defy fundamentals cos of the mad heard mentality...

who on earth can explain why people were buying IT stocks in India during the Nasdaq bubble even after the IT Index was trading at a PE of 400...

Also, who can explain the first speculative bubble recorded in history...where people were buying tulips even by selling their Mania for more on this...

So stocks markets these days have become a place for speculation...they have also become a place of transfer of wealth from the not so rich to the rich and super rich...

If you survey the retain investors...from my knowledge and interaction I can tell you that more then 70% retail investors have lost more money then they have made in the equity markets...

Anonymous,  November 29, 2009 at 8:04 PM  

Dear Kumaran

Can you please let me know the site you use to analyze things like (trading volume).

Thank You

Kumaran December 1, 2009 at 8:59 AM  


I use many sources including yahoo finance india, moneycontrol,, bseindia and others. But you will be able to find most of the things in bseindia.


Pat December 9, 2009 at 2:44 AM  

Hi Kumaran - just got an info on kwality dairy.

In view of the increase in the price of the shares of Kwality Dairy India Limited an examination was carried out by SEBI to look into the dealing of the shares of the company.

It was observed that certain entities were carrying out a cycle of off-market transfer and market transaction i.e. purchase through market, which was repeated a number of

times among them. Thus, by trading in a circular and synchronized manner these entities had generated fictitious trades and given a false misleading impression of large

volumes of trading in the scrip.

With a view to protect the interest of investors and securities market from such acts Dr. K.M. Abraham, Whole Time Member, SEBI has passed an ex-parte ad-interim order

dated December 01, 2009 inter-alia directing:

a. Entities Bhupendra Singh Rathore, Leela Surana R, Mahasagar Securities, Rajesh Kumar Vyas and Rajesh Kumar Vyas not to buy, sell or deal in the securities in any

manner till further directions in this regard.

b. The Sub-broker Surana Capital Market not to buy, sell or deal in the securities of Kwality Dairy India Limited in any manner till further directions in this regard. The

sub-broker is further directed not to buy, sell or deal in the securities in its own account in any manner till further directions in this regard.

The order has come into force with immediate effect.

Anonymous,  December 9, 2010 at 5:53 PM  

Thank you, I have recently been searching for information about this topic for ages and yours is the best I have discovered so far.


This is a blog about stock market investments, investment strategies, and related topics. Any statement made in this blog is merely an expression of concerned authors opinion, and in no case should it be interpreted as an investment advice to buy stocks, sell stocks, or for that matter advice for any other issues be it money related or not. By using this blog you agree to (i) not take any investment decision, or any other important decisions based on any information, opinion, suggestion or experience mentioned or presented in this blog (ii) verify any information mentioned here, independently from your own reliable sources (for e.g. a registered investment advisor) and thereby check for possible inaccuracies. This blog is to create investment wisdom among general population and the authors are not responsible for
any decisions that you make based on the information provided here.
Creative Commons License
Stock Analysis Online by Kumaran Seenivasan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.
Based on a work at

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by 2008

Back to TOP